Sunday, February 28, 2010


Blake Robbins probably thought it was pretty neat when his school, Harriton High School in the wealthy Philadephia suburb of Ardmore. sent a new Macbook laptop computer home with him. His school district, one of the wealthiest in the country, had issued the laptops to its high school students.

But when Blake was called into the Vice-Principal's office and accused of '”inappropriate behavior off school grounds,” he discovered another use for the computers that neither he nor his parents knew about. According to a lawsuit filed in Federal Court, Blake was confronted with pictures of himself, allegedly taking drugs. The pictures had been taken by the built in camera on his own computer.

Now, anyone who's had any contact with the justice system here in the 21st century can probably tell you about defendants who've been undone by taking pictures of themselves brandishing weapons, ingesting drugs, or showing off ill-gotten gains, then posted them on their MySpace and Facebook pages (yes, some criminals really are that dumb).

But that wasn't what happened in Blake's case. He found, to his (and his parents') horror, that the computers contained software that allowed school administrators to turn the cameras on remotely and photograph whatever was in the room with the computer.

At first, the school admitted that it had turned on its all-seeing eyes a total of 42 times, but insisted that the system was only used to track “lost or stolen” laptops. This did not address the question of how Blake's machine, which was neither lost or stolen, had its camera activated so that school administrators could peer into his home.

Later investigations by the Philadelphia Inquirer showed that the network administrator responsible for the laptop program apparently had not gotten the memo about only using the program to search for purloined hardware. In a case of almost too-perfect irony, the administrator, Mike Perbix, had posted his own video on line touting the neat things that could be done when you turned school computers into surreptitious surveillance devices. It showed him, for example, snapping “as many as 20 photos of a teacher and some students without their knowledge while in the classroom.” Perbix apparently thought this was a keen thing to be able to do: “It's a fantastic feature," the Inquirer quotes him as chuckling. I don't know about you, but the idea of some geeky IT guy chuckling over his ability to spy on kids without permission creeps me out.

Blake's parents have now filed a class action suit against the school district. The FBI is also investigating for potential violations of Federal wiretapping laws.

For years, under the banner of “maintaining order”, the schools have demanded increased power to encroach on the privacy and free-speech rights of students. They've also moved to criminalize every behavior problem, to the point where students who commit infractions that would at one time have gotten them sent to the office end up in court, charged with crimes. And the courts, on all levels, have pretty much let them have their way, especially in the post-Columbine world, in which it sometimes seems as if every student is regarded as a criminal by default. In one case that I've written about in this column, a student was locked up when his response to the prompt “write a scary story” led to...well, a scary (and violent) story. In another, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a student could be suspended for a drug-related joke made off campus. In such an environment, why shouldn't a school feel entitled to send surveillance devices home with a student? Especially if he was caught doing drugs?

Except that those “drugs” Blake was supposedly taking turned out to be candy. Something called Ike and Mikes. I'm sure we're all glad that this brave new technology is being deployed to protect us and our children from sugary snacks.

George Orwell, in the book “1984”, wrote about a society in which everyone had a “telescreen,” a device in the wall that provided propaganda broadcasts, but which could also be used by the totalitarian government of Big Brother to keep an eye on citizens. You never knew when the screen was being monitored, so you had to live at all times as if you were being watched.

In 2010, is Big Teacher watching you?


pattinase (abbott) said...

Damn and we thought it would be Communists watching us. It turned out to be software/hardware people.

starviego said...

A great essay. If there is silver lining, it is the awakening of the teens--never a politically astute group--to the reality of our modern police-state control grid. Everybody needs to wake up right now before it is truly too late.

The PaulR said...

I wonder if any of the people who watched the kids at home say them naked at any time? If so, will they be brought up on child porn charges?

Celine said...

Somebody should totally do that shirt design on CafePress. Better still, a generic "Your Friendly Local School District" one, which would both remove any possibility of a C&D from the district and make it applicable as other such cases come to light.

Anonymous said...

Things I can't do at school anymore--never mind in my own home...let's see, mike and ikes's (or pez, good n' plenty, candy cigarettes, lemonheads or even dots--never mind powder sugar straws...) the headache meds I carried around for migraines (extra strength acetaminophen w/ extra caffeine), carry my own carving tools, my knitting needles or my pen knife (I would miss my pen knife).
Thinks I could still do, but might be arrested for--make out like I should get a room, swear like a sailor, read whatever I wanted--provided I use the cloth paperback covers I made in high school so no one would question my choice of reading material.
Oh, and in Michigan--I don't think they failed this little piece of legislation off yet, they might not be able to fund the colleges--but you might be able to carry a gun on their campuses.

Have fun with that JD. I'm beginning to think the 1980s were a more enlightened time, no matter what Ronnie Regan did with my student grants...

Mark said...

I've been amazed how many people defend the school and attack the student. Security at any cost.